Ah snap, right now both Surprise and Wild are gonna generally be the same pattern of boxers.
You'll need to reach out to Customer Service so we can get you changed up.
If you want to get two different patterns via the subscription service, be sure to pick Mild and Wild.
To contact Customer Service -
You'll need to click the, "email us", button. Then, after suggested articles are brought up for you click the "I Still Need Help, Submit my question" button on the bottom left of the popup to send us an email or chat in.
After you hit, "I still need help", above it'll bring up this screen. Then, you can either chat with us during business hours (M-F 9AM-5PM MST) or email us and we'll get you squared away!